Is Soy Infant Formula Safe?

by Tanya
(Seattle)

I am a vegan and unfortunately, I'm not able to breastfeed my baby. I know that breast milk is the best thing I could possibly feed her, but it's not an option. How do you feel about soy infant formula? I don't want to feed her cow's milk, but I have to pick what's healthiest for her. What do you recommend?

Answer:

I understand where you are coming from; you want what's best for your baby and you'll do whatever it takes to figure that out, even if it means sacrificing your beliefs to make her healthy. Sometimes, for some women, breastfeeding just is not an option.

Have you looked into breast milk banks? In case you've never heard of them, I know it sounds a bit creepy to even think about using another woman's milk for your child. But, think about it, what's grosser-- the pus-filled, engorged, bleeding, covered-in-feces cow's udders filling your infant formula with countless chemicals, fertilizers, antibiotics, fungicides and herbicides, or another woman's clean breast milk that has been tested for safety? It's unusual and we tend to shy away from things we aren't used to hearing about, but it's truly the next best thing to your own breast milk.

If you think it might be an option for you, check out the National Milk Bank (www.nationalmilkbank.org) for more details. Granted, you will have to pay for this breast milk, so you can expect it to be more expensive than using your own, but again, it's the next best option, and not much more than buying formula.

As for the next, next best option, I would say that's soy infant formula. Quick note, do not use plain soy milk for infants. Soy infant formula is completely different, with a totally different formula that is safe for babies. Soy milk is deficient in nutrients for babies and if you feed it exclusively, you will likely starve your infant.

Articles written decades ago warned about possible dangers of soy formula, and those warnings have remained in so many mother's minds, but fortunately, more recent research shows that there the worries about manganese levels in soy formula were unfounded. Soy infant formula is safe and balanced in nutrients and you can confidently feed it to your baby if you cannot breastfeed. I would certainly choose it over cow's milk formula if I had to pick because of all the problems associated with consuming dairy products.

Comments for Is Soy Infant Formula Safe?

Average Rating star

Click here to add your own comments

Nov 04, 2012
Rating
star
Your advice may make people ill.
by: Bert

I hope no one follows your advice on what to eat while you are pregnant because it is a diet that will cause malnourishment to the mother and child. I was a vegetarian for 27 years and in that time I have seen many vegan or macro parents feeding their kids what they thought was a nourishing vegan or macro diet while their kids wasted away and had no energy. They always looked gaunt. It was horrible.
How can a diet which has to supplement nutrients in order to be healthy be ... healthy ? It’s the ultimate oxymoron !
If you’re vegan cause you don’t want to hurt animals then God bless you ! But if you vegan cause you think it’s a healthier lifestyle then you are definitely on the road to nowhere !

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Vegan Pregnancy Questions.

Vegan Blog   |   About Me   |   Contact Me   |   Privacy Policy   |   Vegan E-zine

by Cathleen Woods   |   © Copyright 2010-2017   |   Vegan-Momma.com

Disclaimer: Everything in this website is based upon information collected by Cathleen Woods, from a variety of sources. It is my opinion and is not intended as medical advice.
It is recommended that you consult with a qualified health care professional before making a diet change.